Guidance to control airborne infection risks

Guidance to control airborne infection risks: what schools need to know

Hosted by: U.S. EPA and the Efficient and Healthy Schools Program

Webinar Slides, Recording and FAQ

August 2023: In preparation for the new school year, there is new guidance from both CDC and ASHRAE that schools can rely on when deciding what actions to take to reduce airborne infection risks. CDC recommends improving ventilation in buildings using basic strategies, as well as enhanced strategies to improve filtration, air disinfection, and air flow in order to further reduce the concentration of virus particles in the air. ASHRAE’s newly established Standard 241, Control of Infectious Aerosols, establishes minimum requirements for outdoor air ventilation system and air cleaning system design, installation, commissioning, operation and maintenance.

Join us in this webinar to hear from Kenneth Mead, Ph.D., PE, Chief of the Engineering and Physical Hazards Branch in the NIOSH Division of Field Studies and Engineering, and William Bahnfleth, Ph.D., PE, Chair of the ASHRAE Standard 241 Project Committee, on what schools must know to be better prepared to reduce airborne infection risks. You can find frequently asked questions from the webinar below!

Speakers

Kenneth Mead

Dr. Kenneth Mead is a mechanical engineer and industrial hygienist. He is the Branch Chief of the
Engineering and Physical Hazards Branch within the CDC’s National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health (NIOSH). In this role, he oversees a large team of engineers, scientists and support personnel who
design and evaluate engineering control solutions to reduce occupational exposures in traditional and
emergency response environments. Dr. Mead has over 30 years of experience providing occupational
safety and health engineering support, primarily to DoD, construction, and healthcare industries. His
research experience encompasses a wide variety of occupational hazards including exposures to
chemicals, silica, infectious aerosols, hazardous drugs, Anthrax and Ebola. He is a registered professional
engineer, a recognized expert in healthcare facility ventilation issues and serves on multiple committees
within the American Society of Heating, Refrigeration and Air-Conditioning Engineers, now known as
ASHRAE, including his current roles as incoming Chair of ASHRAE’s Technical Committee (TC) 9.6
Healthcare Facilities, outgoing chair of the Subcommittee on Infectious Diseases, and membership on
ASHRAE’s Environmental Health Committee and ASHRAE’s Standard 170 Committee, Ventilation of
Healthcare Facilities. Throughout the CDC’s COVID-19 pandemic response, Dr. Mead has used his
knowledge of controlling infectious aerosols and other contaminants in a leadership role during the
development of CDC’s engineering controls and protective ventilation guidance.

William Bahnfleth

William Bahnfleth is a professor of architectural engineering at The Pennsylvania State University. He holds a PhD in mechanical engineering from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and is a Registered Professional Engineer. He is a fellow of ASHRAE, ASME, and ISIAQ. At Penn State, Dr. Bahnfleth teaches courses in HVAC system design and indoor air quality. His research interests include control of bioaerosols and low-energy/high IAQ HVAC systems. He is the author of more than 180 peer-reviewed papers and 15 books/chapters. Dr. Bahnfleth is a past-president of ASHRAE and 1st Vice-President of the Indoor Environmental Quality Global Alliance. He currently chairs the ASHRAE Environmental Health Committee and SSPC 241 Control of Infectious Aerosols, the committee responsible for developing ASHRAE Standard 241. He previously was chair of the ASHRAE Epidemic Task Force. Dr. Bahnfleth is a Distinguished Alumnus of the University of Illinois Department of Mechanical Science and Engineering and a recipient of the Penn State Engineering Alumni Society World Class Engineering Faculty Award. Among his ASHRAE honors are the Donald Bahnfleth Environmental Health Award, E. K. Campbell Award for teaching, Andrew T. Boggs Service Award, Louise and Bill Holladay Distinguished Fellow Award, and ASHRAE’s highest honor, the F. Paul Anderson Award.

Frequently Asked Questions

Disclaimer: This Q&A was prepared by the Efficient and Healthy Schools Program staff. The following responses do not necessarily represent the views of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), ASHRAE or EPA.

What are ASHRAE and CDC current recommendations for air filtration and ventilation for classrooms?

Both ASHRAE and CDC recommend improving ventilation from a combination of outdoor air, filtration, and air treatment, to help protect building students and staff from respiratory infections.

CDC’s guidance includes basic strategies to make sure that HVAC systems are operating and suggest updating older systems to meet current ventilation standards. CDC suggests 5 or more air changes per hour of clean air from a combination of outdoor air, filtration, and air treatment to help reduce the number of viral particles in the air.

ASHRAE Standards 241-Control of Infectious Aerosols sets the amount of equivalent clean airflow (ECA) for different building and space types when operating under “infection risk management mode” (IRMM). Unlike CDC’s suggested 5 or more air changes of clean air per hour, ASHRAE’s ECA uses a per person metric: 20 L/s of clean air per person for classrooms. Decisions to enable IRMM would be determined by public health officials or other authorities, or can be used at the discretion of the building owner or occupant.

In addition, both ASHRAE and CDC included guidance on best practices to assess, operate, and maintain buildings to mitigate infection risks.

How effective are portable air cleaners and are there recommended specifications when choosing a device?

See CDC’s guidance on using HEPA air cleaners (FAQ #5):

ASHRAE Standard 241 - Control of Infectious Aerosols specifies testing requirements to verify the effectiveness and safety of air cleaning systems, whether they are installed in-room, such as portable air cleaners, or installed in-duct. For portable air cleaners that use only mechanical fibrous filters, the equivalent clean airflow rate should be determined using a method similar to that described in ANSI/AHAM AC-1 adapted with the chamber size criterion outlined in Standard 241 Normative Appendix A.

How can we calculate air changes per hour (ACH)? What particular ACH do you recommend?

CDC provides an explanation and example: “How much ventilation is enough?” When multiple strategies are used, ACH calculation should be repeated for each system, and added together for a total value for comparison with the 5 ACH recommendation.

ASHRAE’s Equivalent Clean Airflow Calculator (ECAC) can be used to determine the existing system’s equivalent clean airflow for infection control and the modifications necessary to achieve the target of 20 L/s of clean air per person for classrooms.

What are CDC and ASHRAE’s recommendations on filter ratings (MERV ratings) that schools should use in their HVAC systems?

CDC recommends upgrading filters to MERV-13 (minimum efficiency reporting value) or higher when possible.

ASHRAE Standard 241 - Control of Infectious Aerosols specifies infectious aerosol removal efficiency of filters for ones that are rated MERV-A 11 or higher. Filters rated lower than MERV-A 11 are deemed ineffective for removing infectious aerosol. MERV-A is determined by using a test method (ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 52.2) where filter efficiency is measured after a conditioning step to mimic real-life filter efficiency degradation that can take place. Starting January 2025, ASHRAE Standard 241 recommends that only MERV-A values be used when determining the infectious aerosol removal efficiency.

What are important points to consider about using far-UV (or UV-C) in classrooms?

CDC provides guidance on using UV to inactivate airborne pathogens in the air. UV systems can provide a high level of effective clean air towards lowering respiratory infection risks. However, they are not a substitute for meeting minimum outdoor air ventilation requirements for schools. CDC provides information on upper-room ultraviolet germicidal irradiation (UVGI): Discussion about whole-room UVGI, or far-UV, are included here (FAQ #7)

ASHRAE Standard 241 - Control of Infectious Aerosols considers ultraviolet (UV) as one of the technologies that can be used to inactivate infectious aerosols. It references ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 185.1 for testing the infectious aerosol reduction efficiency of in-duct UV. Standard 241 also sets safety requirements for all UV technologies, including upper-room UVGI and whole-room UVGI, or far-UV.

What is the efficacy and safety of alternative air cleaning methods such as ionizing technologies?

CDC recommends caution when considering an emerging technology. Common among these are ionization, dry hydrogen peroxide, and chemical fogging. For more information, see (FAQ #8).

Recognizing that lack of information and standards related to air cleaning systems was a major problem during the COVID-19 pandemic, ASHRAE Standard 241 establishes testing requirements for effectiveness and safety for all air cleaning technologies, including UV, electrostatic, photocatalytic, and ionizing systems. For more information, see ASHRAE Standard 241 - Control of Infectious Aerosols Normative Appendix A - Determining air cleaning system effectiveness and safety.

Should schools consider real-time air monitoring?

CDC considers using portable CO2 monitors as part of enhanced strategies that schools can use to determine how stale or fresh the air in rooms. CO2 readings above 800 ppm (parts per million) suggest that there may be a need to bring in more outside air into the building. More discussion around the use of CO2 monitoring, whether integrated with HVAC systems or as standalone measurements, are further discussed here (FAQ #9).

Do recommendations from CDC and ASHRAE change when the outdoor air quality is poor, such as when schools are impacted by wildfire smoke?

CDC’s guidance on wildfire smoke and COVID-19 recommends relying on filtration, such as portable air cleaners that are commercially available and DIY air cleaners, that are effective for removing viral particles and fine particulate matter in wildfire smoke.

More information about DIY air cleaners, see resources: (EPA) and (NIOSH).

While ASHRAE Standard 241 - Control of Infectious Aerosols does not address wildfire smoke, ASHRAE offers guidance in their Planning Framework for Protecting Commercial Building Occupants from Smoke During Wildfire Events: Prepare the building to use higher efficiency filter, assess HVAC systems ahead of time, and use portable air cleaners are among the recommendations included in a smoke readiness plan. These strategies are also mentioned in ASHRAE Standard 241.

How can older schools with outdated HVAC systems meet CDC and ASHRAE recommendations without creating comfort, humidity, and/or other concerns?

Both CDC and ASHRAE prioritize assessment, planning, operation and maintenance as part of their recommendations. All schools regardless of HVAC system types can benefit from assessing their current conditions and make operational improvements, while planning to retrofit outdated systems when there is opportunity to do so.

In addition, because both CDC and ASHRAE recommend improving ventilation from a combination of outdoor air, filtration, and air treatment, schools can consider strategies that are more suitable for their buildings. Schools are not limited to increasing outdoor air ventilation, which has energy implications and may not work in existing HVAC systems, as their only option.

How should schools measure or determine if their infection control strategies are effective?

Evaluation is part of EPA IAQ Tools for Schools’ framework for effective school IAQ management. While it is not written specifically to address airborne infection control, the guiding principles - solicit feedback and capture return on investment, are applicable to documenting the benefits of infection control strategies.

How can schools with limited funding and resources adopt CDC and ASHRAE recommendations? Are there funds available to support their efforts?

There are a number of federal, state, and other resources available that can provide funding and/or technical assistance to schools. One of the key federal funding sources is the Department of Education’s Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief Fund (ESSER) and American Rescue Plan (ARP). Other agencies, like EPA and Department of Energy (DOE), also offer programs to support schools. For example, DOE’s Renew America’s Schools promotes the implementation of clean energy improvements that will lower utilities costs, improve indoor air quality, and foster healthier learning environments:

For more information about funding and resources to support school facilities improvements, please reach out to us at schools@lbl.gov.